Santa Monica Property Tax Relief: Why Post-Fire North of Montana Buyers Should Act Before Nov 30

After the January 2025 fires, families who needed somewhere to land moved fast. North of Montana in Santa Monica, that meant bidding wars and offers well over asking. A year and a half later, many of those homes are worth less than their owners paid, and their property tax bills are still based on the purchase price.

"There are a lot of buyers right now who paid a huge amount, especially north of Montana in Santa Monica, right after the fires," says Paul Salazar. "They wanted to get their family situated, so they were in big bidding wars and paid way over asking price to get in. Then a year later, a year and a half later, they want to sell and they're losing millions of dollars."

If that describes your purchase, you may be paying tax on a price the market no longer supports. LA County lets you ask for a lower assessed value, and the request for this tax year has to be in by Monday, November 30, 2026. We walked through the full filing process in Can I Lower My LA County Property Taxes? This post is for one group in particular: owners who bought north of Montana in 2025 and paid a premium to get in.

Why post-fire buyers are the most likely to be overassessed

Under Proposition 13, your purchase price generally becomes your home's base value for property tax, and it can rise by no more than 2% a year after that (LA County Assessor via SMDP). If you paid well over asking in a bidding war, that premium went straight into your tax base.

Proposition 8 allows a temporary reduction when a home's market value on January 1 falls below its assessed value (LA County). For this round, the date the county looks at is January 1, 2026 (SMDP). For many 2025 buyers, that date landed after prices north of Montana had already started to slip.

What north of Montana prices have done since

Redfin data cited by Grey Square shows the 90402 ZIP code, which covers north of Montana, with lower prices and less competition than a year earlier. In our Q2 2026 Santa Monica market update, we also noted a home on 23rd Street that sold for $10 million in 2026 after selling for $14 million in April 2025.

North of Montana (90402) | 3 months ending July 2026
MeasureNowYear over year
Median sale price$4,748,945Down 10.4%
Price per square foot$1,670Down 8.1%
Sale-to-list price97.4%Down 1.2 points
Listings with a price cut18.5%Not reported

Source: Redfin data cited by Grey Square, September 2026.

Paul is careful not to paint every home with the same brush. "Not all of them, but a lot of them have," he says. "Especially the ones that sold for way over asking price."

That last point is the one to focus on. The more you paid above asking, the wider the gap between your tax base and today's market is likely to be. A buyer who paid close to list price may have little to gain, while a buyer who won a crowded bidding war may have a real case.

The comparable sales that matter for 2025 buyers

The county's review form asks for two comparable sales, meaning sales of similar nearby homes, that closed as close to January 1, 2026 as possible and no later than March 31, 2026. Applications without them are still accepted (Form RP-87). For a north of Montana owner, that means the late-2025 and early-2026 sales on your blocks, not the bidding-war prices from the spring of 2025.

How to tell whether it's worth filing

When an owner asks Paul whether to file, his first step is simple. "First off, I can do a quick search and let them know whether it's worth their time," he says.

The question is whether homes like yours sold for less than your assessed value around January 1, 2026. You can find your assessed value on your 2026-27 tax bill or through the LA County Assessor's portal.

Why Paul recommends hiring a professional

The county's review is free, and you can file it yourself. Paul's advice is to get help anyway. "Doing it on your own is probably not the smartest idea," he says. "It's always good to hire somebody that can do it for you, a professional that does this for a living, and pay them if they're able to win the appeal." He refers owners to a couple of firms that work that way.

If you hire someone, LA County requires tax agents to be registered with the county and to include your written authorization with the application (LA County AAB).

If you're also thinking about selling

A lower assessed value doesn't change what your home will sell for. It lowers what the home costs you to hold while you decide, and a buyer's tax base resets to their own purchase price when ownership changes (SMDP).

What to do before November 30

There are two ways to file, and both are due Monday, November 30, 2026. The Decline-in-Value Review (Form RP-87) goes to the Assessor and is free (Form RP-87). A formal appeal goes to the Assessment Appeals Board, costs $46, and protects your right to a review if the Assessor's answer comes late (LA County AAB), (California BOE). Our step-by-step guide covers both.

Keep paying your bill on time while a request is pending. The first installment of the 2026-27 bill becomes delinquent after December 10, 2026 (LA County Treasurer and Tax Collector). Any reduction is temporary, and your assessed value can rise faster than 2% a year as prices recover (California BOE).

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I lower my property taxes if I overpaid in a bidding war?

Possibly. What counts is not how much you overpaid but whether your home's market value on January 1, 2026 was below its assessed value. If it was, you can ask LA County for a temporary reduction by November 30, 2026.

I bought my Santa Monica home in 2025. Which date does LA County use to judge its value?

LA County looks at your home's market value on January 1, 2026. Comparable sales should close as close to that date as possible and no later than March 31, 2026.

Have home prices dropped north of Montana in Santa Monica?

Yes. Redfin data cited by Grey Square shows the 90402 median sale price down 10.4% year over year for the three months ending July 2026, with price per square foot down 8.1%.

Does a lower assessed value affect what my home will sell for?

No. Your assessed value only sets your property tax. A buyer pays market price, and their tax base resets to their own purchase price after the sale.

Should I hire a property tax consultant to file?

You can file the free review yourself, but Paul Salazar recommends hiring a professional who is paid only if the appeal succeeds. In LA County, tax agents must be registered and need your written authorization to file.

The bottom line

If you bought north of Montana after the fires and paid well over asking, check your number before November 30. If you'd like Paul to run that quick search on your home or connect you with a firm that handles appeals, call 310-853-2643 or email info@paulsalazargroup.com.

Paul Salazar is a real estate agent, not a tax advisor or attorney. This post is general information, so confirm the details for your property with the LA County Assessor or a property tax professional. DRE #01763227.

Next
Next

Should You List Your House Over the Holidays? What 3,600 Westside Listings Say